Blog · Strategy

Choosing AI tools for your firm: a simple scorecard

There's a new AI tool every week, and every one claims to save hours. Most firms end up choosing based on a demo or whatever one enthusiastic person found first. A short scorecard leads to better decisions and fewer subscriptions you regret.

Score each tool from 1 to 3 on these six questions.

1. Does it solve a real problem we have?

Name the task and roughly how much time it takes today. If you can't, the tool is a solution looking for a problem.

2. Will people actually use it?

Run a two-week trial with the people who'd use it daily. Usage at the end of week two tells you more than any demo.

3. What happens to our data?

Check the business terms: is your data used to train models, where is it stored, how long is it kept, and can you delete it? Prefer business plans with clear answers.

4. Can we control it?

Look for company accounts, single sign-on, the ability to add and remove users centrally, and usage reports. These matter more as the team grows.

5. What will it really cost?

Include per-seat prices, usage charges and the time to set it up and train people. Usage-based pricing can be cheap at first and expensive at scale.

6. Does it overlap with what we already pay for?

Many suites you already use now include AI features. Check before adding a new tool for the same job.

Reading the score

A tool scoring 15 or more out of 18 is usually worth a proper rollout. Under 12, keep looking. Either way, write down why you chose it, so you can check six months from now whether it delivered.


Want a second pair of eyes on how your firm uses AI? Book a free 20-minute call.

More from the blog

Let's talk about what you're building.

A free 20-minute call. No sales pitch.

Book a free call